FRAUD PREVENTION · AI IMPERSONATION

A familiar voice or face is no longer proof of who is asking

22,364complaintsto the FBI in 2025 mentioned AI
  • FBI: don’t use contact details the caller gives you
  • EBSA project: protecting benefit distributions
  • DOL: confirm the identity of the funds recipient
Sources: FBI IC3 2025 Annual Report⁠ (opens in new tab); FBI, September 17, 2026; EBSA; DOL best practice #5

The short answer: AI tools can now imitate a plan sponsor’s or participant’s voice, and even fake a video call, well enough that hearing or seeing someone no longer proves who is asking for a distribution, a bank-account change or a payroll change. The defense is mostly procedure: confirm each such request through contact details already on file, have a second person approve it, hold new bank details for about a week, and log what you checked.

Why This Is Happening Now

In its 2025 annual report⁠ (opens in new tab), the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) says “AI-enabled synthetic content is becoming increasingly difficult to detect and easier to make.” It received 22,364 complaints that mentioned AI, with more than $893 million in losses, mostly from investment scams, and notes that “Voice cloning can also be used to request wire payment.”

Recent alerts:

  • November 13, 2024: the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) warned⁠ (opens in new tab) that criminals have reportedly used generative AI to impersonate “an executive or other trusted employee” and redirect payments.
  • September 17, 2026: the FBI said⁠ (opens in new tab) AI lets scammers “appear as law enforcement and government officials on video calls.”
  • November 12, 2026: an FBI alert⁠ (opens in new tab) to cryptocurrency firms described hackers who “play prerecorded webcam videos of previous victims to simulate a legitimate video call with participants the target knows.”

On January 15, 2026⁠ (opens in new tab), the Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) at the Department of Labor (DOL) listed “Protecting benefit distributions” among six national enforcement projects for fiscal year 2026. The DOL’s Cybersecurity Program Best Practices⁠ (opens in new tab) already note that “identity theft is a leading cause of fraudulent distributions.” For court cases, see our recordkeeper integration article; for phishing, The Human Factor: People’s Role in TPA Breaches.

The Verification Playbook

These eight steps are TPAIT’s recommendations, not a regulator’s rules; we cite agency advice where it applies.

  1. Name the requests that always get verified. Distributions, withdrawals and loans; changes to a participant’s bank account, address, email or phone; changes to a sponsor’s authorized contacts, payroll contacts or contribution instructions; your own staff’s direct-deposit changes; and any request for a sign-in code or remote access. The FBI warns⁠ (opens in new tab) that criminals inside a payroll or retirement account “can change the direct deposit information and redirect future payments.”
  2. Call back on a number already on file. Hang up (or set the email aside) and call a number your records held before the request arrived, never one the request supplies. The FBI says “do not use contact information provided by the person contacting you” and “don’t trust caller ID⁠ (opens in new tab).” The Federal Trade Commission’s advice⁠ (opens in new tab): “Don’t trust the voice.” If the number itself is changing, confirm it at the old number.
  3. Use code words with people you know. The FBI tells families⁠ (opens in new tab): “Create a secret word or phrase with your family to verify their identity.” Do the same with sponsor contacts and your own payment approvers. Set it up in person, never email it, and change it when someone leaves. It adds to the callback; it never replaces it.
  4. Require two people. A second person, never the one who took the request, checks the callback record and paperwork before anything goes to the recordkeeper or custodian; for bank changes and full-balance distributions, make it a manager. The DOL’s best practices list “additional validation for distributions (other than a rollover) of the entire balance of the participant’s account.”
  5. Use a cooling-off hold. If bank details, address, email or phone changed in the last 30 days, hold the payment for at least five business days and send a notice to the previous contact details so the real person can object. The DOL’s best practices call for alerts “when an individual’s account information has been changed” and “additional validation if personal information has been changed prior to request for a distribution.”
  6. Treat urgency as a reason to slow down. Pressure is the warning sign: the FBI describes scammers “using urgent and aggressive tones” and “urging victims not to tell” anyone. Give staff a script (“Happy to help. We always call back at the number on file.”) and a written promise that no one is faulted for following it.
  7. Confirm video meetings and IT calls another way. Requests made on video get the same callback. The FBI advises confirming meetings “through an alternate communication method from how you were contacted.” Never read a sign-in code to a caller, even one claiming to be from IT; a May 26, 2026, FBI alert⁠ (opens in new tab) recommends telling staff how IT support will contact them and prove who it is.
  8. Log every request. A short record per request turns a procedure into evidence for sponsors, insurers and EBSA investigations, and answers a question our checklist for plan advisers suggests they ask.

The One-Page Request Verification Checklist

Complete one per request, on paper or in your workflow.

Request verification checklist
CheckWhat to write down
Request receivedDate, time, channel (phone, email, portal, video or paper), who asked, what for
Called back on a number already on fileThe number, where it came from, who answered, when
Code word confirmedYes or no; never the word itself
Recent changes checkedBank, address, email or phone changes in the last 30 days
Hold applied, if details changedStart and release dates; notice sent to the old contact details
Full-balance payout (not a rollover) reviewedWho validated it, and how
Second person approvedName and time; never the person who took the request
Pressure notedUrgency, secrecy, a new payment method or channel; who was told
Exception approvedManager’s name and reason, in writing
Record filedWhere it is kept

What to Tell Plan Sponsors and Participants

Tell plan sponsors in writing, and again when a new contact starts:

  • “We will call you back at the number on file before acting on any distribution, bank-change or payroll-change request.”
  • “We never accept or send new bank or contribution instructions by email alone. If an email from ‘us’ says otherwise, call the number you already have.”
  • “Please confirm your authorized contacts once a year, and tell us the day someone leaves.”
  • “We may ask for the code word we agreed on.”

For participants, the DOL has said most of it in its Online Security Tips⁠ (opens in new tab): “Register, set up and routinely monitor your online account,” “Keep personal contact information current” and “Sign up for account activity notifications.” The tips also warn about messages that “express great urgency.” Add two of your own: your firm will never ask for a password or sign-in code, and a bank change may delay a payment by about a week on purpose.

What We Recommend: Technology That Backs Up the Procedure

This section is TPAIT’s advice. No tool replaces the callback, but three controls make a criminal’s job harder:

  • Phishing-resistant sign-in for staff. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds a second check to the password, but a texted or emailed code can be stolen by a fake website or a convincing caller; the FBI warns that “MFA will not protect you if you land on a fraudulent login page.” Passkeys and physical security keys work only on the genuine website, so there is no code to hand over. The DOL’s best practices say: “Deploy phishing-resistant Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) if possible.”
  • Email authentication for your domain. Three settings, called SPF, DKIM and DMARC, let other mail systems check that a message claiming to come from your firm really did, and reject it if not, so criminals can’t easily email your plan sponsors “from” you. Add alerts for lookalike domain names, as the FBI recommends.
  • Logs someone reads. Keep sign-in records, alerts for new mailbox forwarding rules, and the verification log itself where staff can’t alter them. They answer the sponsor, insurer or EBSA investigator who asks what happened.

Our cybersecurity service includes email security with impersonation detection, phishing-resistant MFA where possible, round-the-clock log monitoring and security awareness training that covers fraudulent distribution requests and plan sponsor impersonation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a cloned voice fool trained staff?

It can. The FBI warned on December 19, 2025, that a cloned voice and a real one “can sound nearly identical.” Rely on the callback, not on spotting fakes.

The caller gave us a number to call back. Is that enough?

No. Use a number your records held before the request arrived. The FBI’s advice: “do not use contact information provided by the person contacting you.”

What do the DOL’s best practices say about distributions?

They say to “Confirm the identity of the authorized recipient of the funds” and list alerts when account information changes, plus extra validation after recent changes and for full-balance distributions other than rollovers. They are best practices, not regulations, but EBSA investigators ask about them.

What if a fraudulent payment has already gone out?

Act the same day. The FBI says “time is of the essence”: ask the institution that sent the payment to recall it, and report it at ic3.gov. The DOL’s best practices also call for informing law enforcement and notifying the appropriate insurer.

This page is general information, not legal advice. Ask your own counsel how the rules apply to your firm.

Want a Second Look at Your Verification Steps?

Book a free 30-minute assessment call. We talk through how your firm handles these requests today and point out what to look at first.

Book a Free Assessment Call⁠ (opens in new tab)